Metabilia

Mystery Collection

Autographed mystery collectibles from every team, in one place.

Kansas City

MYSTERY
BOX
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Photo Mystery Series Incl 50 GOLDEN TIX
Purchase
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Photo Mystery Series Incl 50 GOLDEN TIX
Price
$59
Qty remaining
260
MYSTERY
BOX
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Jersey Mystery Series Incl 5x MAHOMES ✍️ JERSEYS!
Purchase
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Jersey Mystery Series Incl 5x MAHOMES ✍️ JERSEYS!
Price
$99
Qty remaining
152
Chiefs Mystery PSA Slab Hit Box - (1) Graded Chiefs Card | PSA 9 or 10 GUARANTEED! Mahomes, Kelce, Reid & More! + Mahomes Rated Rookie Slab Chase
Purchase
Chiefs Mystery PSA Slab Hit Box - (1) Graded Chiefs Card | PSA 9 or 10 GUARANTEED! Mahomes, Kelce, Reid & More! + Mahomes Rated Rookie Slab Chase
Price
$119
Qty remaining
73
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$125
Qty remaining
97

Cincinnati

MYSTERY
BOX
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Jersey Mystery Series Incl 80 GOLDEN TIX
Purchase
INSTANT MYSTERY - Signed Jersey Mystery Series Incl 80 GOLDEN TIX
Price
$139
Qty remaining
201
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Price
$125
Qty remaining
69
Cincinnati Bengals Signed Mystery Mini Helmet
Purchase
Cincinnati Bengals Signed Mystery Mini Helmet
Price
$125
Qty remaining
99
Cincinnati Bengals Signed Mystery Card
Purchase
Cincinnati Bengals Signed Mystery Card
Price
$40
Qty remaining
85
Cincinnati Bengals Signed 8x10 Photo Mystery
Purchase
Cincinnati Bengals Signed 8x10 Photo Mystery
Price
$40
Qty remaining
96
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$125
Qty remaining
100

Baltimore

Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Price
$125
Qty remaining
73
Baltimore Ravens Signed Mystery Jersey
Purchase
Baltimore Ravens Signed Mystery Jersey
Price
$125
Qty remaining
94
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$125
Qty remaining
92

Tampa Bay

MYSTERY
BOX
Mystery Autographed Custom Jersey
Purchase
Mystery Autographed Custom Jersey
Price
$129
Qty remaining
35
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Price
$125
Qty remaining
80
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$125
Qty remaining
100

Indianapolis

Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Jersey Mystery Bag
Price
$125
Qty remaining
82
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Hall of Fame Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$125
Qty remaining
99

Buffalo Bills

Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$70
Qty remaining
61
Mystery Buffalo Bills Football
Purchase
Mystery Buffalo Bills Football
Price
$80
Qty remaining
16
Mystery Buffalo Bills Full Size Helmet
Purchase
Mystery Buffalo Bills Full Size Helmet
Price
$225
Qty remaining
Only 7 left
Mystery Autographed Slabbed Cards
Purchase
Mystery Autographed Slabbed Cards
Price
$60
Qty remaining
13
Pro-Style Jersey Mystery Box
Purchase
Pro-Style Jersey Mystery Box
Price
$80
Qty remaining
88

Buffalo Sabres

Buffalo Sabres 8x10 Photo Mystery Box
Purchase
Buffalo Sabres 8x10 Photo Mystery Box
Price
$25
Qty remaining
34
Buffalo Sabres Signed Puck Mystery Box
Purchase
Buffalo Sabres Signed Puck Mystery Box
Price
$40
Qty remaining
45
Buffalo Sabres Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Purchase
Buffalo Sabres Signed Mini Helmet Mystery Box
Price
$60
Qty remaining
47